As a Broadway and musical theater lover myself, I am always on the look out for new gifts for the fellow fans in my life. Here's a list of the best Broadway and musical theater inspired goodies online right now - all from small makers/businesses - prices are in USD & these items are available at the time of creating this list.

1) Hamilton Sandstone Car Coasters - Little Shop of Geeks - $7.50 each, $15 set

The most useful musical themed gift you never knew you needed.


2) Broadway Nail Decals (Variety of Shows Available) - NailingBroadway - $8.78 - sets also come in cheaper bundles!

I had never done nail decals before these but they are SO GOOD. These are the perfect gift for a fashionista Broadway fan. Tons of shows represented in different packs, and even a variety pack!

 Broadway nail decals

3) The Last Five Years - Schmuel Song Enamel Pin - One Shop Glory - $6

Jason Robert Brown fans will love this pin - I sure do!

schmuel song pin

4) The Schuyler Sisters Christmas Ornament - Little Shop of Geeks - $18

Angelica, eliza, and peggy... work! Add some Broadway magic to your (or a gift recipient's) Christmas tree with this Hamilton inspired ornament! I love the "include women in the sequel" quote - such a perfect gift for a kick butt feminist like Angelica! ;) 

The Schuyler Sisters Ornament

5) Rent Coloring Pages - Coloring Broadway - $9.95 for 4 pages - cheaper digital download options available!

What's more soothing than mindfully coloring inspirational quotes from your favorite Broadway show?! I love this Rent inspired collection, but they also offer coloring pages for lovers of other musicals.

6) Falsettos - Walter Kerr Theatre Exterior Illustration Print NailingBroadway - $14.37 for 4x6, $19.96 for 5x7

Photo of print

7) Audition Morning Candle - Little Shop of Rose Gold - $15

Amazing packaging, and this shop is run by theater actress in NYC! She has a lot of great gifts for a budding performer - like this candle!

audition morning candle

8) Broadway Playing Cards - Periodic Table of Broadway Musicals - $7.50

A super affordable and fun gift on this list - the periodic table is fun too, but the playing cards are new for the 2020 holiday season!

Broadway Playing Cards

9) Say Yeah! Kinky Boots Bag - Scenery Bags - $75

This company is one of my favorites - they upcycle theater materials that would otherwise hit landfills and make incredible accessories that have so much meaning and history. This Kinky Boots bag made of a red velour curtain from the set was the first Scenery Bags item I ever received as a gift - it is so special to me!

say yeah bag - scenery bags

10) Hamilton Women's Slip-On Canvas Shoes - Little Shop of Geeks - $62

Put some Broadway magic on your feet! These cute illustrations are of Hamilton characters. Also offered in a similar blue background color print. Free shipping!


11) Hamilton NotepadLittle Shop of Geeks - $12


 What do you think?! Any other gifts I should add to this list?